Rental Listings:
Interested in listing your rental property here? Take advantage of this high traffic targeted marketing resource and say goodbye to occasional vacancies at your property!

Simply email your information (address, availability, cost, number of bedrooms, interesting features, etc., as well as your phone number and email address) to us. Then click on the "Buy Now" link below to complete your transaction. Type the address of your rental property in the "Payment For" box. You may also include a link to your own personal webpage if you'd like to show pictures of your property to potential renters or we can create a page for you for an additional one-time charge. Email the above email address for more information. One address per listing. Listing order is based upon a "first come, first served" basis.

Listings are $50 per year.
Click Here for a viewable map of Sunset Bay

12889 A & B Iola Drive corner of Shady across from the Beach Club. Two cottages in the heart of the action. 10 ft. from beach, beautiful lake views, sunsets and sandy beaches. Fully furnished, amenities include gas grill. Guests bring linens.

A: 3 bedroom $950 a week plus security - 3 double beds, 2 couches. 8 person max.
B: 2 bedroom $725 a week plus security - 2 double beds, 1 futon couch. 6 person max.

Available May thru September. Contact us for winter rates. Spring and Fall weekends available (remember opening and closing parties).

Contact MJ at 934-4231 • email


Great Location in the Center of Everything Going On! Two Cottages located four houses down from the Cabana Sam's & deli.  Fully furnished, bring linens and toiletries.  Very nice, very clean cottages.  20 years rental experience with an excellent reputation.

3-Bedroom: 1004 Newton Road, $800.00 a week plus security - (Sat.-Sat.)
Available 2008 season starting in May. $500.00 for monthly winter rates plus utilites.
NEARLY SOLD OUT; June, July & August - Only June 21-June 28th available.

2-Bedroom: 1015 SouthShore Drive, $700.00 a week plus security - (Sat.-Sat.)
Available 2008 season starting in May. $300.00 for monthy winter rate plus utilities.
If you are interested in Cabana Sam's closing party book now for the weekend!
SOLD OUT; June, July & August.

Cottages are available all year round. Winter rentals starting right after labor day by the month or weekends are available.  E-Mail us with your name and address to be put on our mailing list for 2008 summer.    

For detailed information and photos click here

Contact: Robin at 674-3321 or 310-5986 • email


To submit your listing by mail
click here.

Rental listings updates are preformed Monday - Friday during business hours.

12874, 12868A & 12868B Iola Drive Units are two houses down from the beach and Beach Club. All units are 2 bedroom or 3 bedroom, 1 bath, plus two fold out couches. Each unit has parking for a least 4 vehicles.  All units are fully furnished, with kitchen amenities, gas grill, fire pit and beach pass.  Largest unit has A/C. fenced-in yard and large porch.  Guests bring linens, toiletries, and propane.  $950* per week (plus security) Sunday - Sunday. (*4th of July week increased rate). Most weeks are available for 2009.

Weekends are available in April, May, June and September $100-$150 per night.  Winter rental is also available $400-$450 month, including water and sewer.

View website pictures here. Contact: Kelly at (716) 983-5640 or email


This directory is provided as a service and only facilitates the exchange of information between property owners and potential renters.

Sunset Bay Beach Club, Cabana Sam's, Keller Graphics and any of their affiliates do not verify either the information regarding the properties advertised or the identity of the contact person and do not assume responsibility or guarantee the accuracy of the information contained on the individual listings.

Sunset Bay Beach Club, Cabana Sam's, Keller Graphics and any of their affiliates cannot be held responsible for any disputes that may arise between property owners and renters.

Renters are responsible for conducting their own investigation regarding any and all claims made by prospective renters or cottage owners. Renters assume all liability for use of any information they find in this listings directory.
12878 Iola Drive Across from the Beach Club and Beach!
Recently renovated large 2 bath / 4 Bedroom house with laundry and central A/C. Comes fully furnished and includes gas grill, TV, CD player, DVD player, 20 case beer/pop cooler, and a nice back yard. 10 person max occupancy (family atmosphere preferred). $1,100 per week + security.

Weekend Rates available for May and June. For all the luxuries of home with an at the beach atmosphere call Sam at 716-510-2957 or 716-694-4900 or email


View website pictures here.

Beautiful Beach House Fully furnished, carpeted, 2 bedrooms (each w/double bed, 2 dressers, ceiling fan), large living area with pull-out couch, washer & dryer, covered front porch, private backyard garden w/concrete patio & furniture, propane gas grill & picnic table. Walking distance to beach & beach club. Amenities; firewood, 2 VIP beach club passes, 2 beach passes, full private driveway. No smoking, pets, or garage use.

Available for the 2008 Season starting in May for $850.00 a week plus security.
Guests brings linens and toiletries. Rental is from Sunday to Sunday. Winter Rates available starting Labor Day. Contact Tim or Linda at 716-648-1209



12916 Ontario St. Waterfront cottage located along peaceful Cattaraugus creek. Minutes by foot to the Beach Club. Fully furnished, 2 bedroom, bathroom, large living room, kitchen and dining rooms.  TV/DVD. Fold out couch sleeps an additional 2 people. Large yard with fire pit. Grill available, but must supply your own propane. Guests bring linens and toiletries. Quiet setting ideal for families. No large groups.

$700 per week. Rental is from Sat. 1pm - Sat 11am. Most summer weeks available.
Dock space also available on a seasonal or weekly basis.

For detailed information and photos click here


Contact: Rich at (716) 825-3890 email, or Chris at (716) 994-9615 email


Great Location to Rent or Own 100 Yards from the Beach. 2 & 3 bedroom cottages at 12865 Alleghany Road. Well-maintained. Access to beach & back cottage through Beach Club's lot. Huge yard with fire pit & picnic tables. Free parking for 4 cars per cottage. Fully furnished. Guests bring linens, toiletries & firewood.

Weekly rentals: June, July & August, Sat. 12pm - Sat. 10 am. $625 - $725 per week
+ security. Weekend rentals: Spring & Fall only, 2 nights $185 - $215, checkout 5pm.

Contact: Linda (716) 674-1240